An Austin Cold Case Goes from No Suspects to Three

Lyla Reese
10 min readJan 3, 2022

The 1985 murder of a music-loving mother and Cuban immigrant, Natalie Antonetti.

Credit: CBS News

In the early morningš‘‹Sunday, October 13, 1985, Susan Otten found her roommate, Natalia (Natalie) Antonetti, 38, bleeding from her head, speaking incoherently; 18-days later, she was dead.

In the 1960s, Natalie fled a Castro-led Cuba with her three younger sisters. The sisters lived independently in various American cities but stayed close as they built families in the United States.

Only 15-months before her death, the music-loving Natalie established a home for herself and her son, Johnny Goudie, 16, in Austin, Texas. They lived with Susan in an apartment on Barton Hills Drive. Natalie, a former teacher, worked at Native Son Plant Nursery and had a landscaping businessš‘‹The Wildside. Many of her co-workers were musicians, so it wasnā€™t uncommon for her to have friends over for dinner + music or frequent music clubs.

Hours before her attack, Natalie visited Steamboat Springs and Toulouse, neighboring clubs on Austinā€™s famed Sixth Street. After parting with her friends at 2:00 am, she returned home around 2:30 am. She changed her clothes and went for a walk in the complex. After returning 10 minutes later, she spoke to Susan and fell asleep on theā€¦

--

--

Lyla Reese
Lyla Reese

Written by Lyla Reese

True Crime ā€” Freelance Writer

No responses yet